The Transcript
It seems like every morning before school, Ashley, 15, argues with her parents about how she’s dressed. They think she looks inappropriate; she says she’s just expressing her individuality. Now she keeps begging her parents about getting her nose pierced. They decide to have a talk.
MOM: Ashley, we want to have a talk with you about your appearance.
ASHLEY: Again?! I’m so tired of you bugging me all the time. I really don’t see what the problem is with how I dress.
DAD: We’re tired of arguing every time you leave the house, too, so we thought we’d sit down with you now to see if we can come up with a compromise. It’s a chance for us to hear each other out without getting into another heated discussion.
ASHLEY: Okay. Well, like I said yesterday morning, I don’t see what’s so bad about my clothes. I’m just expressing myself. The same way you probably did when you were a teenager.
MOM: We understand that. And we admire your individuality. But we’re worried that your appearance may unfairly influence people’s perception of you. We know how bright and responsible you are, but the way you look sometimes suggests otherwise.
DAD: We just don’t want you to be hurt by it. We know it’s unfair that people judge and make assumptions, but that’s how the world works.
ASHLEY: A lot of kids dress like me. I think you guys are overreacting. Not everyone is as old-fashioned as you.
DAD: We don’t want to control how you look…we understand that is part of who you are. We’d just like you to consider the consequences.
ASHLEY: I think it just tells people that I’m creative and unique.
MOM: We’d like to propose a compromise. We want you to dial it back a bit during the week and dress a little more conservatively. If you want to dress a little different when you’re spending time with your girlfriends on the weekends, then that would be okay.
ASHLEY: I’m not going to totally change how I look, just because you guys can’t handle it!
MOM: We’re not asking you to do that. We just want to find some middle ground. Can you work with us on this, please?
ASHLEY: Fine. I’ll try it. But I still want to get my nose pierced!
MOM: Tell us why you want to get it pierced.
ASHLEY: Because it’s a unique way for me to express myself. I think it looks cool.
DAD: There are a lot of downsides to doing something so permanent. Why don’t you do some research and put together a list of pros and cons. We’ll take a look at that and then talk about it again.
MOM: I think you should also talk to someone who’s had it done. And I want you to talk to Dr. Olson, too, to see what he thinks. Then we’ll discuss it, but we’re not promising anything.
ASHLEY: Okay. Thanks.